After reading about dangerously handsome fae warriors who would burn down entire kingdoms for the women they love, how exactly are we supposed to get excited about a man who takes three days to reply to a text? Sarah J. Maas has a lot to answer for.
Spoiler warning: This article contains major spoilers for A Court of Thorns and Roses, including the recently released A Court of Splintered Harmony.
There is a very particular kind of romantic disappointment that happens after reading Sarah J. Maas’s A Court of Thorns and Roses. One minute you’re emotionally invested in a 500-year-old High Lord who can read minds, move mountains and offer you an entire city. The next you’re back on Hinge, staring at a 29-year-old man called Josh whose personality apparently consists of golf, espresso martinis and a photograph of himself holding a fish. It’s enough to send you straight back to Prythian, or at least desperately searching through our best books to read after ACOTAR in the hope that another fictional man might restore your faith in romance.
Because let’s face it, Sarah J. Maas has created something of a problem for heterosexual women. A very attractive, frequently shirtless, occasionally winged problem.
For years, women have been told that their romantic expectations are unrealistic. That they should stop looking for Prince Charming, lower their standards and understand that real relationships involve compromise.
And then along came Rhysand.
A man who is devastatingly handsome, obscenely wealthy, sexually enthusiastic, fiercely devoted and capable of transporting you to another location without the indignity of sitting in traffic.
He also has wings.
Good luck competing with that, Josh.
Somewhere Between Velaris and Hinge, Dating Became Deeply Disappointing
The modern dating experience is, by almost any romantic measure, rather bleak.
You match with someone. You exchange messages. You spend several days establishing that you both enjoy travelling, good food and laughing, three interests apparently shared by every single person currently alive.
Eventually, somebody suggests meeting for a drink.
Not dinner, obviously. That would imply an unacceptable level of commitment. Just a casual drink, preferably somewhere sufficiently convenient that neither party has to make any meaningful effort.
You arrive, make polite conversation, establish whether there’s chemistry and attempt to work out if the man sitting opposite you is emotionally available or merely very good at pretending.
If things go well, he might text the next day.
If things go exceptionally well, he may even suggest a second date without requiring a seven-day consultation period.
Meanwhile, the fictional men of Prythian are making life-altering declarations, crossing dangerous territories and quietly falling in love with women who haven’t even noticed them yet.
The contrast is, frankly, embarrassing. Of course, we understand that Rhysand isn’t real. We’re not completely delusional. We simply think it would be nice if a real man occasionally planned a date without needing three separate reminders and a Google Maps link.
Rhysand Has Set the Bar Ridiculously High. And He’s Not Even Perfect.
Let’s discuss the man responsible for much of this nonsense.
Rhysand, High Lord of the Night Court, ruler of Velaris and arguably one of the most romantically disruptive fictional characters of the past decade.
He’s powerful, sarcastic, intelligent and spectacularly attractive. He lives in a beautiful city, owns multiple properties and seems to have an almost unlimited budget for expensive clothes, jewels and elaborate romantic gestures.
He also pays attention.
And perhaps that’s the most dangerous part.
He notices what Feyre needs. He recognises her abilities. He wants her to become powerful in her own right, even when that means challenging the expectations of everyone around her.
He helps her find a place where she belongs, surrounded by people who become her chosen family.
Yes, there are significant caveats. Rhys has his controlling moments, his spectacularly questionable decisions and a particularly unfortunate tendency to believe that withholding information is acceptable if his intentions are good.
In the real world, we’d have some fairly serious conversations about that.
But the central romantic fantasy remains enormously appealing.
Here is a man who finds the woman he loves fascinating. Not merely attractive, convenient or someone who might produce children and remember when the recycling needs to go out.
Fascinating.
And for women navigating a dating culture where enthusiasm is sometimes treated as a character flaw, that level of attention can feel positively revolutionary.
The fantasy isn’t necessarily that a man would destroy a kingdom for you.
It’s that he might be genuinely interested in what you have to say over dinner.
Although the kingdom would be a nice bonus.
Unfortunately, A Court of Splintered Harmony Has Made Things Even Worse
Just when readers thought they had a reasonable understanding of the romantic situation in Prythian, Sarah J. Maas released A Court of Splintered Harmony and threw what little emotional stability the fandom had left directly into the Cauldron.
And nowhere is the situation more deliciously chaotic than the continuing drama involving Azriel, Elain and Gwyn.
For years, readers have debated whether Azriel would end up with Elain Archeron, the gentle, mysterious Seer whose Cauldron-chosen mate is Lucien, or Gwyneth Berdara, the priestess and Valkyrie who has developed an intriguing connection with the notoriously brooding Shadowsinger.
In A Court of Splintered Harmony, the situation becomes considerably more complicated.
Azriel and Elain have been secretly involved, despite the political consequences and Rhysand’s earlier warning to stay away from her. Their relationship is exposed in spectacular fashion when Lucien discovers them together.
Naturally, this goes terribly.
There is fury, betrayal, confrontation and an enormous amount of emotional fallout. Rhysand is furious. Lucien walks away from the Night Court. Azriel finds himself increasingly isolated, and Elain eventually leaves with Mor on a diplomatic mission to Vallahan.
Honestly, it’s like an especially disastrous episode of Love Island, except the contestants have centuries-old grudges, magical powers and the possibility of a fight to the death.
But the most interesting part isn’t even the scandal. It’s the shadows.
Azriel’s shadows repeatedly retreat from Elain, something he appears to welcome because their absence gives him a sense of quiet. Unfortunately, their disappearance also leaves him unaware of danger, including Lucien’s approach.
Around Gwyn, however, the shadows behave very differently.
They seem drawn to her, eagerly responding to her presence and singing.
Now, whether this points to a future romance, a deeper magical connection or something else entirely remains unresolved. We would strongly advise against announcing an endgame based on the behaviour of a collection of sentient shadows.
And here’s where the whole thing starts to feel suspiciously like modern dating.
Azriel is emotionally complicated, drawn to someone unavailable and seemingly incapable of having a straightforward conversation about his feelings. Elain is caught between a bond she never asked for and a relationship that creates chaos around her. Gwyn, meanwhile, may be developing a connection with a man whose romantic history is enough to make any sensible woman consider moving to another continent.
We’ve all known an Azriel.
Admittedly, ours probably worked in finance and had a motorcycle.
The Problem With Azriel Is That He’s Exactly the Type of Man Women Should Probably Avoid
Let’s be clear. Azriel is extraordinarily attractive.
He’s mysterious, powerful, loyal and brooding. He has an appealingly dangerous profession, a tragic backstory and enough unresolved emotional baggage to require an entire separate checked-in suitcase.
He is also, from a romantic perspective, something of a logistical nightmare.
He spent centuries harbouring feelings for Mor, developed an attraction to Elain despite her existing mating bond and now has this tantalising connection with Gwyn.
And in A Court of Splintered Harmony, rather than solving his emotional problems through reasonable adult conversation, he manages to create a scandal that threatens friendships and political alliances.
This is not ideal boyfriend behaviour. In real life, we’d probably tell our friend to avoid him.
We’d explain that she deserves somebody who knows what he wants, communicates clearly and isn’t currently embroiled in a complicated romantic situation involving several women and a potentially fatal duel.
We would say all this very firmly over a bottle of wine.
Then we’d go home, open the book and immediately fall in love with Azriel ourselves.
Because fiction allows us to enjoy the deliciously terrible decisions we would never recommend making in real life.
And perhaps that’s the real appeal. We don’t necessarily want the emotionally complicated man. We want the fantasy that we might be the person who finally makes him feel safe enough to be understood.
Which, as romantic strategies go, has historically been responsible for an alarming number of disappointing relationships.
The Mating Bond Is Basically Everything Women Wish Dating Apps Could Deliver
There is something undeniably seductive about the idea of a mating bond. Imagine not having to worry whether somebody likes you.
No analysing messages. No asking your friends what a particular emoji means. No wondering why a man who seemed extremely enthusiastic on Saturday has suddenly become unavailable until Thursday.
Just a magical connection announcing that this person is your destined partner.
Wonderful.
Until you remember that Elain has a mating bond with Lucien and doesn’t particularly want it. Suddenly, the fantasy becomes rather more complicated. Because what happens when destiny chooses someone you haven’t chosen for yourself? What if your supposedly perfect match isn’t the person you love?
What if you’re drawn to somebody else entirely, and that attraction threatens to destroy several important political relationships?
It’s the sort of problem that makes Hinge look almost straightforward.
And it raises an interesting question about modern dating.
Do women genuinely want a soulmate, or do they simply want certainty?
Perhaps the appeal of the mating bond isn’t that the universe has selected your perfect partner.
Perhaps it’s the prospect of finally knowing where you stand.
Because after six months of a situationship with a man who refuses to discuss the future, the promise of a supernatural connection that actually means something begins to sound rather appealing.
Even if it does come with a complicated set of ancient fae laws.
Tamlin Is the Reminder That Not Every Grand Romantic Gesture Is Romantic
Of course, we can’t discuss ACOTAR and dating without addressing Tamlin.
The original love interest. The handsome High Lord. The man who initially seemed capable of offering Feyre a beautiful, protected life.
Until protection started looking increasingly like control.
And that’s where Maas’s stories become more interesting than simply a collection of attractive men behaving dramatically.
Because a man can be powerful, devoted and completely obsessed with you while still being entirely wrong for you.
In fact, obsession can be a remarkably effective disguise for possessiveness.
When someone insists they know what’s best for you, decides which risks you’re allowed to take and gradually limits your freedom, the fact that they’re doing it because they love you doesn’t automatically make it romantic.
It makes it something you should probably discuss with your friends.
Preferably before moving into his enormous country estate.
For all the fantasy of powerful men and passionate relationships, one of ACOTAR’s more compelling messages is that love shouldn’t require a woman to become smaller.
And that’s a standard worth bringing into the real world.
No wings required.
But Have Fictional Men Actually Made Our Standards Too High?
This is where the criticism of romantasy readers becomes rather predictable.
Women are accused of expecting too much.
They want men who are handsome, wealthy, emotionally intelligent, sexually attentive, protective without being controlling, mysterious without being secretive and devoted without being suffocating.
They want excitement and stability.
Danger and safety.
A man who can command an army but also recognise when they’re having a bad day.
Yes, when you put it like that, the expectations seem a little ambitious.
But strip away the magical powers, wings, centuries of experience and questionable military activities, and what’s left?
A desire to be understood.
To feel wanted.
To have a partner who notices things, remembers conversations and makes an effort without being asked.
To enjoy a relationship where affection isn’t a negotiation and commitment isn’t treated as an embarrassing sign of emotional weakness.
Are those really unreasonable expectations?
Of course, some romantasy relationships would be absolutely appalling in real life. A man who controls your movements, keeps dangerous secrets or solves disagreements with violence is not suddenly desirable because he has an impressive wingspan.
And we probably shouldn’t be using fictional immortals as a literal dating checklist.
But perhaps the popularity of these books reveals something about the emotional experiences women are missing, or simply craving more of, in their romantic lives.
The extraordinary devotion is fictional.
The desire to feel deeply loved isn’t.
Maybe We’re Not Looking for Rhysand. Maybe We’re Just Tired of Men Who Don’t Try.
Here’s the uncomfortable part. Much of what makes ACOTAR’s romantic heroes so appealing isn’t actually supernatural. It’s effort. It’s attention. It’s emotional investment.
It’s the sense that the woman at the centre of the story matters enormously to someone else.
And in a dating culture where people are encouraged to appear detached, remain casual and avoid showing too much interest too soon, that kind of enthusiasm can feel almost embarrassingly old-fashioned.
We’re told not to double text. Not to seem too keen. Not to ask where things are going. Not to reveal that we’d actually quite like a committed relationship with somebody who remembers our birthday and occasionally buys us flowers.
Meanwhile, the men in romantasy are delivering extraordinary declarations of love with complete sincerity.
They’re not worried about appearing desperate. They’re not waiting forty-eight hours to reply. They’re not pretending to be busy to maintain the upper hand. They’re busy fighting ancient monsters and protecting entire civilisations, yet somehow still find time for a romantic conversation.
Meanwhile, Josh has had a difficult week at work and can’t commit to dinner until he sees how Saturday is looking.
It does make you wonder.
And the obsession isn’t limited to ACOTAR. From the dangerous romance of Fourth Wing to the complicated relationships explored in From Blood and Ash, romantasy repeatedly returns to the same appealing idea: being genuinely, profoundly chosen.
Not because you’re convenient.
Not because you happen to be available.
But because somebody sees who you are and wants you anyway.
The Real Fantasy Isn’t the Wings. It’s Being Loved Without Having to Beg for It.
Perhaps the reason ACOTAR has become such a romantic obsession isn’t that women genuinely expect to meet a fae warrior at their local wine bar.
It’s that these books offer an escape from the exhausting ambiguity of modern dating.
In Prythian, feelings are enormous. Attraction matters. Love is transformative. Relationships have consequences.
Characters make spectacular mistakes, behave terribly and occasionally require a few hundred pages to develop the emotional intelligence of an average adult.
But the romantic stakes are never insignificant.
Nobody is casually seeing someone for eleven months while refusing to define the relationship.
Well, perhaps Azriel.
And that’s exactly why A Court of Splintered Harmony is such an interesting development. Beneath the fantasy, magic and increasingly complicated romantic entanglements, it raises questions that are remarkably familiar.
Is chemistry enough?
Can you be drawn to someone who isn’t right for you?
Does being destined for someone mean you should choose them?
And can an emotionally complicated man actually make a relationship work without taking everyone around him down with him?
We might be discussing fae warriors, but the conversations aren’t particularly different from the ones happening over cocktails on a Friday night.
The names are just better. And there are significantly more swords.
So, Has ACOTAR Ruined Dating? Possibly. But Maybe That’s Not Such a Bad Thing.
Eventually, most of us will close the book.
We’ll return to our ordinary lives, our jobs, our friendships and the imperfect business of finding or maintaining love with actual human beings.
We’ll accept that real men cannot fly, summon darkness or communicate through magical bonds.
We’ll recognise that nobody should be expected to provide the kind of obsessive devotion that makes for wonderful fiction but might become rather alarming in an actual suburban relationship.
We’ll understand that real love is often quieter than fantasy.
It’s remembering someone’s coffee order. Showing up when things are difficult. Apologising properly. Being kind when nobody is watching.
It’s a man who makes dinner when you’re exhausted, listens when you’re upset and doesn’t turn every disagreement into a full-scale political crisis.
These things might not sound particularly exciting compared with an ancient warrior declaring his eternal devotion.
But they’re rather wonderful.
And perhaps the healthiest thing romantasy can teach us is not to demand perfection, but to stop confusing a lack of effort with emotional sophistication.
We don’t need men to fight wars for us.
We don’t need palaces or mating bonds or a centuries-old promise that we’re the centre of somebody’s universe.
We just want romance, kindness, passion and a little bit of enthusiasm.
And maybe someone who can make a dinner reservation without acting like they’ve been asked to negotiate peace between the Autumn and Night Courts.
Until then, there’s always another book.
And if Gwyn and Azriel do eventually end up together in A Court of Forgotten Melody, due in January 2027, we reserve the right to become completely unreasonable about fictional men all over again. At least the shadows seem enthusiastic.
After reading about dangerously handsome fae warriors who would burn down entire kingdoms for the women they love, how exactly are we supposed to get excited about a man who takes three days to reply to a text? Sarah J. Maas has a lot to answer for.
Spoiler warning: This article contains major spoilers for A Court of Thorns and Roses, including the recently released A Court of Splintered Harmony.
There is a very particular kind of romantic disappointment that happens after reading Sarah J. Maas’s A Court of Thorns and Roses. One minute you’re emotionally invested in a 500-year-old High Lord who can read minds, move mountains and offer you an entire city. The next you’re back on Hinge, staring at a 29-year-old man called Josh whose personality apparently consists of golf, espresso martinis and a photograph of himself holding a fish. It’s enough to send you straight back to Prythian, or at least desperately searching through our best books to read after ACOTAR in the hope that another fictional man might restore your faith in romance.
Because let’s face it, Sarah J. Maas has created something of a problem for heterosexual women. A very attractive, frequently shirtless, occasionally winged problem.
For years, women have been told that their romantic expectations are unrealistic. That they should stop looking for Prince Charming, lower their standards and understand that real relationships involve compromise.
And then along came Rhysand.
A man who is devastatingly handsome, obscenely wealthy, sexually enthusiastic, fiercely devoted and capable of transporting you to another location without the indignity of sitting in traffic.
He also has wings.
Good luck competing with that, Josh.
Somewhere Between Velaris and Hinge, Dating Became Deeply Disappointing
The modern dating experience is, by almost any romantic measure, rather bleak.
You match with someone. You exchange messages. You spend several days establishing that you both enjoy travelling, good food and laughing, three interests apparently shared by every single person currently alive.
Eventually, somebody suggests meeting for a drink.
Not dinner, obviously. That would imply an unacceptable level of commitment. Just a casual drink, preferably somewhere sufficiently convenient that neither party has to make any meaningful effort.
You arrive, make polite conversation, establish whether there’s chemistry and attempt to work out if the man sitting opposite you is emotionally available or merely very good at pretending.
If things go well, he might text the next day.
If things go exceptionally well, he may even suggest a second date without requiring a seven-day consultation period.
Meanwhile, the fictional men of Prythian are making life-altering declarations, crossing dangerous territories and quietly falling in love with women who haven’t even noticed them yet.
The contrast is, frankly, embarrassing. Of course, we understand that Rhysand isn’t real. We’re not completely delusional. We simply think it would be nice if a real man occasionally planned a date without needing three separate reminders and a Google Maps link.
Rhysand Has Set the Bar Ridiculously High. And He’s Not Even Perfect.
Let’s discuss the man responsible for much of this nonsense.
Rhysand, High Lord of the Night Court, ruler of Velaris and arguably one of the most romantically disruptive fictional characters of the past decade.
He’s powerful, sarcastic, intelligent and spectacularly attractive. He lives in a beautiful city, owns multiple properties and seems to have an almost unlimited budget for expensive clothes, jewels and elaborate romantic gestures.
He also pays attention.
And perhaps that’s the most dangerous part.
He notices what Feyre needs. He recognises her abilities. He wants her to become powerful in her own right, even when that means challenging the expectations of everyone around her.
He helps her find a place where she belongs, surrounded by people who become her chosen family.
Yes, there are significant caveats. Rhys has his controlling moments, his spectacularly questionable decisions and a particularly unfortunate tendency to believe that withholding information is acceptable if his intentions are good.
In the real world, we’d have some fairly serious conversations about that.
But the central romantic fantasy remains enormously appealing.
Here is a man who finds the woman he loves fascinating. Not merely attractive, convenient or someone who might produce children and remember when the recycling needs to go out.
Fascinating.
And for women navigating a dating culture where enthusiasm is sometimes treated as a character flaw, that level of attention can feel positively revolutionary.
The fantasy isn’t necessarily that a man would destroy a kingdom for you.
It’s that he might be genuinely interested in what you have to say over dinner.
Although the kingdom would be a nice bonus.
Unfortunately, A Court of Splintered Harmony Has Made Things Even Worse
Just when readers thought they had a reasonable understanding of the romantic situation in Prythian, Sarah J. Maas released A Court of Splintered Harmony and threw what little emotional stability the fandom had left directly into the Cauldron.
And nowhere is the situation more deliciously chaotic than the continuing drama involving Azriel, Elain and Gwyn.
For years, readers have debated whether Azriel would end up with Elain Archeron, the gentle, mysterious Seer whose Cauldron-chosen mate is Lucien, or Gwyneth Berdara, the priestess and Valkyrie who has developed an intriguing connection with the notoriously brooding Shadowsinger.
In A Court of Splintered Harmony, the situation becomes considerably more complicated.
Azriel and Elain have been secretly involved, despite the political consequences and Rhysand’s earlier warning to stay away from her. Their relationship is exposed in spectacular fashion when Lucien discovers them together.
Naturally, this goes terribly.
There is fury, betrayal, confrontation and an enormous amount of emotional fallout. Rhysand is furious. Lucien walks away from the Night Court. Azriel finds himself increasingly isolated, and Elain eventually leaves with Mor on a diplomatic mission to Vallahan.
Honestly, it’s like an especially disastrous episode of Love Island, except the contestants have centuries-old grudges, magical powers and the possibility of a fight to the death.
But the most interesting part isn’t even the scandal. It’s the shadows.
Azriel’s shadows repeatedly retreat from Elain, something he appears to welcome because their absence gives him a sense of quiet. Unfortunately, their disappearance also leaves him unaware of danger, including Lucien’s approach.
Around Gwyn, however, the shadows behave very differently.
They seem drawn to her, eagerly responding to her presence and singing.
Now, whether this points to a future romance, a deeper magical connection or something else entirely remains unresolved. We would strongly advise against announcing an endgame based on the behaviour of a collection of sentient shadows.
But try explaining that to BookTok.
For readers who followed our ACOTAR 6 recap and the major storylines leading into A Court of Splintered Harmony, the new developments have only made the romantic possibilities more interesting.
And here’s where the whole thing starts to feel suspiciously like modern dating.
Azriel is emotionally complicated, drawn to someone unavailable and seemingly incapable of having a straightforward conversation about his feelings. Elain is caught between a bond she never asked for and a relationship that creates chaos around her. Gwyn, meanwhile, may be developing a connection with a man whose romantic history is enough to make any sensible woman consider moving to another continent.
We’ve all known an Azriel.
Admittedly, ours probably worked in finance and had a motorcycle.
The Problem With Azriel Is That He’s Exactly the Type of Man Women Should Probably Avoid
Let’s be clear. Azriel is extraordinarily attractive.
He’s mysterious, powerful, loyal and brooding. He has an appealingly dangerous profession, a tragic backstory and enough unresolved emotional baggage to require an entire separate checked-in suitcase.
He is also, from a romantic perspective, something of a logistical nightmare.
He spent centuries harbouring feelings for Mor, developed an attraction to Elain despite her existing mating bond and now has this tantalising connection with Gwyn.
And in A Court of Splintered Harmony, rather than solving his emotional problems through reasonable adult conversation, he manages to create a scandal that threatens friendships and political alliances.
This is not ideal boyfriend behaviour. In real life, we’d probably tell our friend to avoid him.
We’d explain that she deserves somebody who knows what he wants, communicates clearly and isn’t currently embroiled in a complicated romantic situation involving several women and a potentially fatal duel.
We would say all this very firmly over a bottle of wine.
Then we’d go home, open the book and immediately fall in love with Azriel ourselves.
Because fiction allows us to enjoy the deliciously terrible decisions we would never recommend making in real life.
And perhaps that’s the real appeal. We don’t necessarily want the emotionally complicated man. We want the fantasy that we might be the person who finally makes him feel safe enough to be understood.
Which, as romantic strategies go, has historically been responsible for an alarming number of disappointing relationships.
The Mating Bond Is Basically Everything Women Wish Dating Apps Could Deliver
There is something undeniably seductive about the idea of a mating bond. Imagine not having to worry whether somebody likes you.
No analysing messages. No asking your friends what a particular emoji means. No wondering why a man who seemed extremely enthusiastic on Saturday has suddenly become unavailable until Thursday.
Just a magical connection announcing that this person is your destined partner.
Wonderful.
Until you remember that Elain has a mating bond with Lucien and doesn’t particularly want it. Suddenly, the fantasy becomes rather more complicated. Because what happens when destiny chooses someone you haven’t chosen for yourself? What if your supposedly perfect match isn’t the person you love?
What if you’re drawn to somebody else entirely, and that attraction threatens to destroy several important political relationships?
It’s the sort of problem that makes Hinge look almost straightforward.
And it raises an interesting question about modern dating.
Do women genuinely want a soulmate, or do they simply want certainty?
Perhaps the appeal of the mating bond isn’t that the universe has selected your perfect partner.
Perhaps it’s the prospect of finally knowing where you stand.
Because after six months of a situationship with a man who refuses to discuss the future, the promise of a supernatural connection that actually means something begins to sound rather appealing.
Even if it does come with a complicated set of ancient fae laws.
Tamlin Is the Reminder That Not Every Grand Romantic Gesture Is Romantic
Of course, we can’t discuss ACOTAR and dating without addressing Tamlin.
The original love interest. The handsome High Lord. The man who initially seemed capable of offering Feyre a beautiful, protected life.
Until protection started looking increasingly like control.
And that’s where Maas’s stories become more interesting than simply a collection of attractive men behaving dramatically.
Because a man can be powerful, devoted and completely obsessed with you while still being entirely wrong for you.
In fact, obsession can be a remarkably effective disguise for possessiveness.
When someone insists they know what’s best for you, decides which risks you’re allowed to take and gradually limits your freedom, the fact that they’re doing it because they love you doesn’t automatically make it romantic.
It makes it something you should probably discuss with your friends.
Preferably before moving into his enormous country estate.
For all the fantasy of powerful men and passionate relationships, one of ACOTAR’s more compelling messages is that love shouldn’t require a woman to become smaller.
And that’s a standard worth bringing into the real world.
No wings required.
But Have Fictional Men Actually Made Our Standards Too High?
This is where the criticism of romantasy readers becomes rather predictable.
Women are accused of expecting too much.
They want men who are handsome, wealthy, emotionally intelligent, sexually attentive, protective without being controlling, mysterious without being secretive and devoted without being suffocating.
They want excitement and stability.
Danger and safety.
A man who can command an army but also recognise when they’re having a bad day.
Yes, when you put it like that, the expectations seem a little ambitious.
But strip away the magical powers, wings, centuries of experience and questionable military activities, and what’s left?
A desire to be understood.
To feel wanted.
To have a partner who notices things, remembers conversations and makes an effort without being asked.
To enjoy a relationship where affection isn’t a negotiation and commitment isn’t treated as an embarrassing sign of emotional weakness.
Are those really unreasonable expectations?
Of course, some romantasy relationships would be absolutely appalling in real life. A man who controls your movements, keeps dangerous secrets or solves disagreements with violence is not suddenly desirable because he has an impressive wingspan.
And we probably shouldn’t be using fictional immortals as a literal dating checklist.
But perhaps the popularity of these books reveals something about the emotional experiences women are missing, or simply craving more of, in their romantic lives.
The extraordinary devotion is fictional.
The desire to feel deeply loved isn’t.
Maybe We’re Not Looking for Rhysand. Maybe We’re Just Tired of Men Who Don’t Try.
Here’s the uncomfortable part. Much of what makes ACOTAR’s romantic heroes so appealing isn’t actually supernatural. It’s effort. It’s attention. It’s emotional investment.
It’s the sense that the woman at the centre of the story matters enormously to someone else.
And in a dating culture where people are encouraged to appear detached, remain casual and avoid showing too much interest too soon, that kind of enthusiasm can feel almost embarrassingly old-fashioned.
We’re told not to double text. Not to seem too keen. Not to ask where things are going. Not to reveal that we’d actually quite like a committed relationship with somebody who remembers our birthday and occasionally buys us flowers.
Meanwhile, the men in romantasy are delivering extraordinary declarations of love with complete sincerity.
They’re not worried about appearing desperate. They’re not waiting forty-eight hours to reply. They’re not pretending to be busy to maintain the upper hand. They’re busy fighting ancient monsters and protecting entire civilisations, yet somehow still find time for a romantic conversation.
Meanwhile, Josh has had a difficult week at work and can’t commit to dinner until he sees how Saturday is looking.
It does make you wonder.
And the obsession isn’t limited to ACOTAR. From the dangerous romance of Fourth Wing to the complicated relationships explored in From Blood and Ash, romantasy repeatedly returns to the same appealing idea: being genuinely, profoundly chosen.
Not because you’re convenient.
Not because you happen to be available.
But because somebody sees who you are and wants you anyway.
The Real Fantasy Isn’t the Wings. It’s Being Loved Without Having to Beg for It.
Perhaps the reason ACOTAR has become such a romantic obsession isn’t that women genuinely expect to meet a fae warrior at their local wine bar.
It’s that these books offer an escape from the exhausting ambiguity of modern dating.
In Prythian, feelings are enormous. Attraction matters. Love is transformative. Relationships have consequences.
Characters make spectacular mistakes, behave terribly and occasionally require a few hundred pages to develop the emotional intelligence of an average adult.
But the romantic stakes are never insignificant.
Nobody is casually seeing someone for eleven months while refusing to define the relationship.
Well, perhaps Azriel.
And that’s exactly why A Court of Splintered Harmony is such an interesting development. Beneath the fantasy, magic and increasingly complicated romantic entanglements, it raises questions that are remarkably familiar.
Is chemistry enough?
Can you be drawn to someone who isn’t right for you?
Does being destined for someone mean you should choose them?
And can an emotionally complicated man actually make a relationship work without taking everyone around him down with him?
We might be discussing fae warriors, but the conversations aren’t particularly different from the ones happening over cocktails on a Friday night.
The names are just better. And there are significantly more swords.
So, Has ACOTAR Ruined Dating? Possibly. But Maybe That’s Not Such a Bad Thing.
Eventually, most of us will close the book.
We’ll return to our ordinary lives, our jobs, our friendships and the imperfect business of finding or maintaining love with actual human beings.
We’ll accept that real men cannot fly, summon darkness or communicate through magical bonds.
We’ll recognise that nobody should be expected to provide the kind of obsessive devotion that makes for wonderful fiction but might become rather alarming in an actual suburban relationship.
We’ll understand that real love is often quieter than fantasy.
It’s remembering someone’s coffee order. Showing up when things are difficult. Apologising properly. Being kind when nobody is watching.
It’s a man who makes dinner when you’re exhausted, listens when you’re upset and doesn’t turn every disagreement into a full-scale political crisis.
These things might not sound particularly exciting compared with an ancient warrior declaring his eternal devotion.
But they’re rather wonderful.
And perhaps the healthiest thing romantasy can teach us is not to demand perfection, but to stop confusing a lack of effort with emotional sophistication.
We don’t need men to fight wars for us.
We don’t need palaces or mating bonds or a centuries-old promise that we’re the centre of somebody’s universe.
We just want romance, kindness, passion and a little bit of enthusiasm.
And maybe someone who can make a dinner reservation without acting like they’ve been asked to negotiate peace between the Autumn and Night Courts.
Until then, there’s always another book.
And if Gwyn and Azriel do eventually end up together in A Court of Forgotten Melody, due in January 2027, we reserve the right to become completely unreasonable about fictional men all over again. At least the shadows seem enthusiastic.
Where to Next?
Still emotionally invested in Prythian? Find out which ACOTAR character matches your star sign, explore our guide to ACOTAR 6 and 7 and the Valkyrie Cycle, or discover which ACOTAR Court you would belong to. Because if modern dating isn’t delivering, relocating to Velaris is beginning to sound increasingly reasonable.
Share this:
Like this: