Fashion

Fly the Flag (Or Don’t): Is It OK to Wear the Merch If You’re Not a Superfan?

a woman searching for a vinyl record

Fashion has always bridged a gap between outfit and conversation starter. Personal style is personal, but it can certainly provoke questions that you may or may not wish to answer. And when it comes to merchandise, there can be moments when you find yourself fending off the persistent questions of a gatekeeper. A band tee, or a team cap can send any number of messages. So you may find yourself wondering: is it OK if you can’t name every track on Nevermind, or are fuzzy on when the Raiders last won a Super Bowl*? Here is the case for wearing just what you like, without the need for a cram session.

You don’t need a pop quiz to get dressed

We’ve all met the type. Sometimes we may have been the type: the person who spots a T-shirt, asks a trivia question, and decides whether the wearer is “allowed” to wear it based on their answer. This is a common enough incident, but let’s be reasonable: clothes are a language. Sometimes you’re fluent; sometimes you’re getting the hang of the alphabet; sometimes you just like a quote. All three are entirely valid.

If a logo, a crest, or album art grabs you, that’s reason enough to include it in your rotation. Respect the origin, don’t claim expertise you don’t have, and you’ll handle most social moments without undue discomfort.

young woman sitting on a yellow sofa while eating her pizza

Sports-branded style: From sideline to streetwear

Team merch hasn’t been limited to game-attending fans for a long time now. These days it’s streetwear currency. A box-fresh cap strikes a balance between athleisure, weekend wear and something to hide that three-day hair. To wear it with confidence, the following tips may come in handy.

  • Balance the palette: If you’re rocking a black and silver Raiders cap, wear it with monochrome basics to keep the look clean and modern.
  • Wear it with intention: If you’re looking to dress for an off-duty winter’s day, a tailored coat with a hoodie, topped off with the cap is good for a streamlined look.
  • Own your story: If you can’t tell your Derek Carr from your Geno Smith, it’s OK to say “I like the design” or even “I’m getting into the sport, I’m still new”. If anyone pushes it, it’s very much a them problem.

From a fashion perspective, classic silhouettes and neutral tones will get the most regular wear; New Era caps will help you find the sweet spot between heritage lids and fresh releases.

Music Tees: Can you wear a Nirvana T-shirt if you can’t name the albums?

In short, yes. Longer answer? Still yes, but try to at least be respectful of the band’s heritage and fans. Band tees are part of the culture: iconic album covers, band logos, or tour dates stitched into cotton. If you like the look but haven’t yet dug into the back catalog, now’s your chance: treat the tee like a playlist recommendation from future you. 

Wearing a t-shirt of any band is fine as long as you’re prepared to tread a line. Don’t claim to be into the scene if you really haven’t heard a note of their music. Be honest. If you like the colors and the design, say so. If people come at you with the old “Oh, you like that band, do you? Name three of their songs!” be disarmingly honest.

“I’m new to them, I really just loved the logo – what would you recommend as a starting point?”

And then, take the recommendation. Worst-case scenario, you don’t like it that much and you extend the “getting into it” period for a little longer. More likely, you’ve found something new to listen to. If the t-shirt is a rarity, wear it with respect; otherwise just enjoy the look and the fit. 

smiling man standing on road near buildings
Photo by Jonathan Del Poente

Politically-adjacent apparel: Navigating a tricky line

Clothes can signal values, but they can also trigger debate where you’d rather just enjoy a relaxed coffee with friends. If you want the aesthetic but not the policy discussion, stay broad with what you’re wearing and keep it non-partisan. Kindness, advocacy, the environment and local issues. Avoid direct party symbols, confrontational slogans and specific names if you don’t want to feel like you’ve been beamed on to the set of Meet the Press. To keep it drama-free, consider the following points:

  • If you want to rep a specific side (for your own reasons), keep it to colors and motifs that at least allow space for plausible deniability if you don’t want to have a tense conversation
  • Aim for inclusive messages – charity campaigns and community clubs over partisan sloganeering
  • If you want to be more strident with your messaging but avoid discord should the context change, go for pin badges that can be removed as required.

Ethics and respect

Without wishing to get into a long analysis of what is and is not respectful when it comes to outfits, bear in mind that what we are discussing here is wearing an outfit or an item for its look and style. If we like the message, the music, or the sports team that comes with it, that’s great, but we’re talking fashion first here. And so the focus should always be on shying away from controversy, and any conversations that are prompted should be able to be had comfortably and with maturity. 

If indeed you do want to be strident with political messaging, that’s a separate issue and it is to be presumed that you’re ready for any conversation that comes from it. That’s up to you, but if the statement is primarily fashion and personal style, it might be best to stay away from apparel which in any way references conflict; also from cultural emblems which do not represent a culture you are a part of. Avoid cosplaying – it may be just a symbol to you, but to other people it could be a lot more. 

You don’t have to pass a series of tests and ask for permission to wear a well-made cap or a logo you love. Be honest about what you know and don’t know, and take the opportunity to find out more. Be open to learning and respectful of what symbols mean to others, and you won’t go far wrong.

Discover more from

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading