Let’s be honest: Williamsburg, VA might not be the first place you think of when someone says “foodie destination.” But if you know where to look, you’ll find a seriously good mix of comfort food, creative dishes, and low-key gems that locals swear by.
If you’re a William & Mary student who’s over meal swipes, a local looking to branch out, or just visiting and don’t want to get stuck at a chain restaurant, this list is your go-to. Here are the best places to eat in Williamsburg right now, no tourist traps, just good food worth leaving the house for.
Rick’s isn’t trying to be trendy, and that’s exactly why it works. This place is all about fast, flavorful Philly-style cheesesteaks, loaded fries, and a local crowd that keeps coming back for more. It is that big city Philly vibes in Williamsburg, VA.
Why It’s a Favorite:
The cheesesteaks are legit – flavorful, cheesy, and messy in all the right ways.
The menu also includes burgers, hoagies, and golden fries that are always hot.
Dessert is underrated: cannolis should not be overlooked.
Outdoor seating = dog-friendly vibes. This is always a plus in Williamsburg.
They stay connected to the community – sponsoring local events and showing up for W&M students.
They’ve also been stepping up their Instagram game with behind-the-scenes content and daily updates. It’s the sort of place that feels like it belongs here, but also a place that makes you feel like you are in a big town.
What to Order:
The Original Cheesesteak with Fries – Don’t overthink it.
Cheesesteak Eggrolls if you’re feeling adventurous. The eggrolls are made fresh.
Cannolis to go. Always a good way to finish up the meal.
Best Time to Go:
Lunch, early dinner, or when you’re starving and want some excellent comfort food.
Blue Talon is cozy without being cramped, upscale without being uptight, and the kind of place you can go in jeans or dress up a little. It feels like a small Parisian café – but in downtown Williamsburg.
What Makes It Special:
A menu full of French-inspired comfort food done really well.
A great mix of locals, tourists, and W&M folks on any given day.
Ideal for brunch dates, long lunches, or a casual dinner that still feels special.
What to Order:
French Onion Soup to start – it’s rich, cheesy, and super satisfying.
Steak Frites or Rotisserie Chicken for a main.
Crêpes if you’re into something lighter but still cozy.
Best Time to Go:
Brunch on the weekend, lunch with friends, or a midweek dinner when you want something different.
Amber Ox is that spot you recommend when someone says, “I want somewhere cool with good food and drinks.” It’s trendy, but not in a try-hard way. The kind of place where everything feels intentional, and tastes even better.
Why People Love It:
Southern-inspired dishes with a twist, think comfort food with upgrades.
They brew their own beer, and it actually pairs well with the food.
The space has chill, industrial vibes and is always buzzing but not too loud.
What to Order:
The Biscuit Board – warm biscuits + spreads = perfect for sharing.
AO Bacon Burger or Shrimp & Grits – can’t go wrong.
This place is fun. The menu’s got variety, the space is playful, and there are conversation starters at every table – literally. You’ll leave full and knowing who in your group would time-travel to the past or future. (It’s a thing.)
What Makes It Different:
The menu covers everything from meatloaf to crab cakes.
The vibe is casual and a little quirky in a good way.
It’s one of those spots that works for families, friend groups, or chill date nights.
What to Order:
Grandma’s Meatloaf or Pot Roast – pure comfort food.
Shrimp & Grits or Crab Cakes if you’re going seafood.
BBQ Ribs (when they’re on the menu).
Best Time to Go:
Dinner with friends or a solid lunch break while exploring the area.
This is one of those places where you walk in and immediately feel like everything’s going to be good. It’s comfortable, the menu’s got something for everyone, and the service is always solid.
Why It’s a Staple:
Classic American menu that doesn’t play it safe – it just does it well.
Feels upscale without being too fancy for families.
You’ll almost always leave saying, “We should come back here.”
What to Order:
2nd St Burger or Smokehouse Burger for comfort food fans.
VA Seafood Roll if you want something a little lighter.
Seasonal seafood entrée, always a good bet.
Best Time to Go:
Dinner with family or lunch when you want a quality meal that’s not too heavy.
Berret’s gives you options: upscale seafood inside, or a more casual grill-and-beer setup outside with live music. Either way, it’s a go-to for anyone who wants fresh, local seafood without the fuss.
Why People Go Back:
Fresh oysters, daily fish specials, and great cocktails. Oysters are great!
The Taphouse Grill, located out back, is a more casual option, featuring live music and patio seating.
Perfect location if you’re walking around downtown. You can go light, listen to some music, have a good time, and then go back out there to explore.
What to Order:
Oysters on the Half Shell (especially during $1 happy hour).
Signature Crab Cakes
Fresh Catch of the Day — always rotating, always good.
Best Time to Go:
Afternoon oyster hour or a relaxed dinner outside on a warm evening.
Fat Canary is Williamsburg’s fine dining flex — but in a way that still feels grounded. It’s the kind of place you book for birthdays, anniversaries, or just because you deserve a great meal with perfect wine.
Why It’s a Must for Foodies:
Seasonal, chef-driven dishes that feel refined but never fussy.
Award-winning wine list with smart pairings.
The space is elegant but never over the top.
What to Order:
Pan-Seared Scallops or Lamb Chops
Seasonal entrées — let the staff guide you
Definitely ask about wine pairings — their sommelier knows what’s up
Best Time to Go:
Celebrations, fancy date nights, or when you just want to treat yourself. (Book ahead, it fills up fast.). Additionally, their downstairs wine bar is fantastic if you’re looking for a good quality wine.
Final Bite 🍴
Williamsburg may be known for its history, but its food scene is quietly killing it. Whether you’re digging into a cheesesteak at Rick’s, splitting a biscuit board at Amber Ox, or sipping wine over scallops at Fat Canary – you’re in for a good time. The Williamsburg food scene is only going to get better, so never count them out!
So skip the touristy chains and eat like you actually live here. Your stomach and taste buds will thank you.
Let’s be honest: Williamsburg, VA might not be the first place you think of when someone says “foodie destination.” But if you know where to look, you’ll find a seriously good mix of comfort food, creative dishes, and low-key gems that locals swear by.
If you’re a William & Mary student who’s over meal swipes, a local looking to branch out, or just visiting and don’t want to get stuck at a chain restaurant, this list is your go-to. Here are the best places to eat in Williamsburg right now, no tourist traps, just good food worth leaving the house for.
1. Rick’s Cheesesteak Shop
🧀 Big flavor. Zero pretense. – ORDER NOW
Rick’s isn’t trying to be trendy, and that’s exactly why it works. This place is all about fast, flavorful Philly-style cheesesteaks, loaded fries, and a local crowd that keeps coming back for more. It is that big city Philly vibes in Williamsburg, VA.
Why It’s a Favorite:
They’ve also been stepping up their Instagram game with behind-the-scenes content and daily updates. It’s the sort of place that feels like it belongs here, but also a place that makes you feel like you are in a big town.
What to Order:
Best Time to Go:
Lunch, early dinner, or when you’re starving and want some excellent comfort food.
2. Blue Talon Bistro
🥖 Comfort food, but make it French.
Blue Talon is cozy without being cramped, upscale without being uptight, and the kind of place you can go in jeans or dress up a little. It feels like a small Parisian café – but in downtown Williamsburg.
What Makes It Special:
What to Order:
Best Time to Go:
Brunch on the weekend, lunch with friends, or a midweek dinner when you want something different.
3. Amber Ox Public House
🍺 Southern roots, modern edge.
Amber Ox is that spot you recommend when someone says, “I want somewhere cool with good food and drinks.” It’s trendy, but not in a try-hard way. The kind of place where everything feels intentional, and tastes even better.
Why People Love It:
What to Order:
Best Time to Go:
Weekend lunch, happy hour, or dinner with a crew.
4. Food for Thought
💬 Good food + good vibes.
This place is fun. The menu’s got variety, the space is playful, and there are conversation starters at every table – literally. You’ll leave full and knowing who in your group would time-travel to the past or future. (It’s a thing.)
What Makes It Different:
What to Order:
Best Time to Go:
Dinner with friends or a solid lunch break while exploring the area.
5. The Hound’s Tale
🍔 Creative food, cozy energy.
The Hound’s Tale is artsy, casual, and just a little unexpected. It feels like a neighborhood pub but with better food and way more personality.
Why It’s Worth a Stop:
What to Order:
Best Time to Go:
Lunch or early dinner, especially if you want something casual with a little flair.
6. Second Street American Bistro
🍽️ Consistent, crowd-pleasing, and local-loved.
This is one of those places where you walk in and immediately feel like everything’s going to be good. It’s comfortable, the menu’s got something for everyone, and the service is always solid.
Why It’s a Staple:
What to Order:
Best Time to Go:
Dinner with family or lunch when you want a quality meal that’s not too heavy.
7. Berret’s Seafood Restaurant & Taphouse Grill
🦪 Two vibes. One seafood powerhouse.
Berret’s gives you options: upscale seafood inside, or a more casual grill-and-beer setup outside with live music. Either way, it’s a go-to for anyone who wants fresh, local seafood without the fuss.
Why People Go Back:
What to Order:
Best Time to Go:
Afternoon oyster hour or a relaxed dinner outside on a warm evening.
8. Fat Canary
🍷 Special occasion vibes, without the pressure.
Fat Canary is Williamsburg’s fine dining flex — but in a way that still feels grounded. It’s the kind of place you book for birthdays, anniversaries, or just because you deserve a great meal with perfect wine.
Why It’s a Must for Foodies:
What to Order:
Best Time to Go:
Celebrations, fancy date nights, or when you just want to treat yourself. (Book ahead, it fills up fast.). Additionally, their downstairs wine bar is fantastic if you’re looking for a good quality wine.
Final Bite 🍴
Williamsburg may be known for its history, but its food scene is quietly killing it. Whether you’re digging into a cheesesteak at Rick’s, splitting a biscuit board at Amber Ox, or sipping wine over scallops at Fat Canary – you’re in for a good time. The Williamsburg food scene is only going to get better, so never count them out!
So skip the touristy chains and eat like you actually live here. Your stomach and taste buds will thank you.
Share this:
Like this: